An Easier Way to Raise Money

Written by Jim Bush, Principal and President

You can raise significantly more money each year by just keeping your current donors happy and fulfilled. A 1% increase in retention rates can mean as much as $123,000 in new revenue next year. 

Donor retention isn’t hard.  Clearly it’s worthwhile.  So why are we, as fundraising professionals, on a giant hamster wheel of inefficiency—replacing nearly half of our donors every year?

Donor attrition can be catastrophic.

Consider a nonprofit with 10,000 donors. With a 60% retention rate, its donor base falls to 6,000 in year two. After five years, the organization has only 780 donors left. 

Why Low Donor Retention Rates?

We don’t know exactly why donor retention rates are so low.  Maybe it’s because we’re obsessed with the new and the shiny.  Or maybe our boards push us to recruit new donors because they think that means more awareness for our cause. It’s time that we, as fundraising professionals, prioritize retention rates and revenue—and educate our boards. 

Serious ROI

The Fundraising Effectiveness Project estimates that if an organization (one that raises at least $5 million per year) raises its donor retention rate by just 1%, they will add $123,194 to their bottom line the following year.  If they raise their retention rate by 10%, that’s $1,231,940 in new revenue the next year.  And if retention rates rise year after year, these results are compounded for even greater growth.

Figure 1: The Fundraising Effectiveness Project’s 2015 Donor Retention Supplement shows the impact of a 1% rise in retention rates for various sized organizations shown on the chart’s left-hand side.

Donor Retention is Key to Major Gifts

The average major donor doesn’t become a major donor until after they’ve given five gifts. At current retention rates, half of your major gift prospects walk out the door each year.  These are donors who have already expressed an interest in your mission.  You’ve already accomplished the difficult task of donor identification and acquisition; keeping them should be equally as important.   

If your organization is considering a capital campaign in the coming years, you’ll need a strong and committed donor pool—one that has been carefully cultivated and engaged. A revolving door of donors fails to create that base of supporters you need for visionary projects that will transform your organization or institution.

How to Retain Your Donors:

  • Thank your donors repeatedly.  Actively show them what their gift means to the children, students, animals, sick, homeless you serve.
  • Treat your donors as investors.  Engage them in your organization through surveys, special donor meetings, or non-fundraising insider events.
  • Educate your board around the importance of retention and its potential ROI.
  • Welcoming new donors with open arms.  Carefully segment them and show them some special love. When it’s time to renew their gift next year, thank them for their first-year investment and ask them to give again.

Ask Us

We know that with more revenue, you can do more to help advance your mission.  To thank you and give back, we are offering a free 15-minute donor retention analysis.  You’ll learn how to improve your rates and raise more funds. 

Let the Winkler Group discuss your donor retention rates and give you suggestions to boost them.  Schedule a 15-minute call that will get you on the road to retention ROI.

Latest Resources & Events

Three Steps to New Major Donors for Your Independent School

September 13, 2023

Discover the secret to finding and cultivating new major donors for your independent school with these three essential steps. Learn how to track annual fund gifts, leverage the power of gratitude, and build meaningful relationships with potential donors.

Header image featuring an elementary school-aged girl throwing clay in a classroom. Header for blog on independent schools and effective annual appeals.

Crafting the Perfect Annual Appeal for Your School

September 01, 2023

Delve into the world of annual school appeals through practical tips and real-life examples. See how message delivery influences results and gain insights to craft winning appeals. We wish you a fruitful annual fund season!

Ready to launch a capital campaign?

What can we help you find?